You could make a fairly convincing argument that Katherine Heigl made the biggest mistake of her career in 2008, which caused her to get written off Grey’s Anatomy. Heigl had won an Emmy for her role as Izzie Stevens the year before, but in 2008 she chose to withdraw her name from the race, which is fine. It’s the reason why she did it that got her trouble.
“I did not feel that I was given the material this season to warrant an Emmy nomination and in an effort to maintain the integrity of the academy organization, I withdrew my name from contention,” Heigl told the Los Angeles Times that year. “In addition, I did not want to potentially take away an opportunity from an actress who was given such materials.”
It was a pretty big slap in the face for the writers, and showrunner Shonda Rhimes, to hear one of their own go out and diss them for their work, and obviously it didn’t sit well with them. Heigl’s character was written off the show not long after, but noticeably she wasn’t killed off, which a lot of people thought might mean a return for Izzie.
In 2016, Heigl admitted that she made a huge mistake saying those things about the writers, and even said she had to go to therapy to deal with it.
“I didn’t feel good about my performance and there was a part of me that thought, because I had won the year before, that I needed juicy, dramatic, emotional material,” Heigl told Howard Stern.
Heigl went to Rhimes to try and apologize for what she said, as well.
“I went in because I was really embarrassed,” Heigl recalled. “So I went in to Shonda and said, ‘I’m so sorry. That wasn’t cool, and I should not have said that.’ And I shouldn’t have said anything publicly. But at the time, I didn’t think anyone would notice … I just quietly didn’t submit and then it became a story, and I felt I was obligated to make my statement, and … ‘Shut up, Katie.'”
“I had never done therapy until a couple years ago,” Heigl continued. “I started going because of the [pauses] scrutiny. I was not handling it well. I was feeling completely like the biggest piece of s–t on the bottom of your shoe. I was really struggling with it and how to not take it all personally and not to feel that there’s something really deeply wrong with me.”
It’s been eight years since Heigl left Grey’s Anatomy, and with the show Suits ending soon, which Heigl is on, people are wondering if maybe she could make a return to the long-running medical drama.
“I haven’t [thought about Izzie] in years,” Heigl admitted. “I don’t know. I don’t know if I would or if I wouldn’t. I almost feel like that would almost be distracting again to, sort of, what they’ve done with that show in the years since I left… and what that’s become and what it is to the fans now. It must feel like it would just be kind of like, ‘Yeah, we already let that go… why are you here?’”
When Heigl left the show, her character was recovering from cancer. She was also married to fellow doctor Alex Karev, and that storyline was left a little undone. Karev has since moved on and married Jo Wilson, but Heigl does admit that her hypothetical return could add something to that whole relationship.
“It would be juicy,” she said. “It would bring out maybe a bit of drama.”
Grey’s Anatomy definitely loves the drama, but I don’t think we’ll be seeing an Izzie appearance any time soon.
Would you like to see Katherine Heigl come back to Grey’s Anatomy?
Grey’s Anatomy is the longest-running medical drama on television, and there’s an idea that the cast and crew have always been one big happy family. After all, how can you not be when you’ve been working together for 15 years?
But, Ellen Pompeo, who plays Meredith Grey, spoke with Variety as part of their “Actors on Actors” series, and admitted that there were “many moments” where she wants to quit the show because of how awful the behind-the-scenes culture was.
“It’s funny: I never wanted off the bus in the year that I could get off,” she said of leaving the show. “The first 10 years we had serious culture issues, very bad behavior, really toxic work environment. But once I started having kids, it became no longer about me. I need to provide for my family.”
Pompeo said that because she had kids, that’s what kept her going. It wasn’t until later on in the series that things started to change for the better.
“At 40 years old, where am I ever going to get this kind of money?” she continued. “I need to take care of my kids. But after season 10, we had some big shifts in front of the camera, behind the camera.”
The actress then continued, saying that instead of leaving the show, she decided to do her best to change the culture on set. It was too important to fix the problem.
“It became my goal to have an experience there that I could be happy and proud about, because we had so much turmoil for 10 years,” she said. “My mission became, this can’t be fantastic to the public and a disaster behind the scenes.”
Pompeo pointed to creator Shonda Rhimes as a big reason as to why there was a shift, especially for the women on the set.
“I now have three kids. And we turned the culture around,” she continued. “I’ve hit some marks that have made me feel accomplished in a different way. Shonda Rhimes has been amazing. She lets us be mothers. I don’t have to travel. I don’t have to go anywhere.”
When Patrick Dempsey left Grey’s Anatomy, Rhimes and Pompeo decided to “rewrite the ending” of that storyline, because the network didn’t think the show would survive without Dempsey’s character.
“That’s what’s kept me,” she said. “Patrick Dempsey left the show in season 11, and the studio and network believed the show could not go on without the male lead. So I had a mission to prove that it could. I was on a double mission.”
Pompeo also spoke of the pay discrepancy between her and Dempsey, despite them having the same ranking on the show. At the beginning, Dempsey was making “almost double” what Pompeo was even though she’s the title character.
“He had a television quote. I had never done TV. ‘He’s done 13 pilots.’ Well, none of them have gone,” she said. “I didn’t even realize until we were renegotiating season 3. No one was offering that up.”
Now, Pompeo makes a reported $575,000 per episode, in addition to a seven-figure signing bonus. She’s encouraging women to speak out about inequity in the workplace.
“My husband says, ‘Closed mouths don’t get fed,’ ” she said. “But if you have to walk, don’t be a victim. If you don’t get what you want, put your big-girl panties on …You can know your worth, but if they don’t know it, you can’t cry.”
Even though the atmosphere on the show has improved, Pompeo says she “hasn’t been challenged creatively at all” recently.
“Every once in a while we do an amazing storyline,” she said. “But for the last five years, I’ve had other milestones that we were trying to achieve behind the camera.”
It’s always interesting to hear behind-the-scenes stories about our favorite TV shows, because it reminds us that the grass isn’t always greener on the other side.
Grey’s Anatomy has been on for such a long time, it’s hard to believe that there was a time when it wasn’t part of our daily lives. It’s been 15 years of doctors Meredith Grey, Alex Karev, Richard Webber, Cristina Yang, and everyone else, and we wouldn’t have it any other way.
Any fan of the show will tell you that, yes, it’s started to decline in quality. That’s not to say it’s not still good, but it’s just not the level it used to be at. Most of us are still watching because we’ve been with the show so long, but nothing will beat the early seasons of the medical drama.
Instead of focusing on the negatives, let’s take a look at the best episodes the show has ever seen. Obviously we can’t put all of them on here, but these are the episodes we’ll never be able to forget, for better or for worse. Keep in mind: these are in no particular order.
1. Into You Like A Train
Episode: Season 2, Episode 6
Why we won’t forget it: This was the episode that made us all sob, and I’d argue it was the first time we really understood just how good this show was going to be. Bonnie and Tom, two characters we’ve never met before this episode, come to the hospital after being impaled on a metal pole in a train crash.
We grew to love these characters in the short time we knew them, and when Bonnie realized she was the one who was going to die, it was absolutely heartbreaking to watch how she handled it. Meredith didn’t want to leave Bonnie to die, yelling “What about her? We can’t just abandon her?” It gives me goosebumps to think about it. Bonnie was young, she had so much life to live, and she died with grace.
2. Dark Was The Night
Episode: Season 8, episode 9
Why we won’t forget it: All Cristina wanted was to learn from Teddy. Teddy was the first teacher to really teach Cristina about cardio, so when Owen convinced Cristina to operate on Teddy’s husband without her knowledge, you just knew it was going to end poorly.
While on the table, Cristina can’t save Teddy’s husband, Henry, and he ends up passing away. When Cristina finds out that it’s Henry, you can feel the crushing sadness. I remember yelling at my TV during this episode, but I don’t know if I was yelling in anger at Owen or yelling in support of Cristina. Honestly, it was probably both.
3. Didn’t We Almost Have It All?
Episode: Season 3, Episode 25
Why we won’t forget it: How could I ever forget Meredith having to cut Cristina out of her wedding dress after Preston Burke left her at the alter? I won’t forget, I can’t forget. This was one of the most pinnacle moments of the series, because even though it was heart-wrenching to watch Cristina lose the love of her life, I truly think it made her a better person.
If Cristina had married Burke, I think she would have lived in his shadow and wouldn’t have grown into the strong, incredible surgeon she came to be. What made Cristina so special was that she knew her career was what she wanted, and she didn’t let anyone get in the way of that.
4. Now Or Never
Episode: Season 5, Episode 24
Why we won’t forget it: George O’Malley deserved better. He did. I know he died a hero, and I know he was doing the right thing, but poor George deserved to have a wonderful life. At the very least, he deserved to die with his friends and family being able to recognize him.
When George came into the hospital, no one knew it was him, but there was a feeling that John Doe would end up being someone the audience recognized. As George starting writing “007” in Meredith’s hand, I’ll admit I didn’t know what it meant at first. Then it clicked. Then I cried. To me, this was the saddest death on the show, but George deserved more than what Seattle Grace Hospital could give him.
Episode: Season 8, Episode 24
Why we won’t forget it: Some will argue that the plane crash episode of Grey’s is where it jumped the shark, and I can see where they’re coming from. How could a plane crash in the woods and not kill everyone, or at least seriously injure them?
That being said, the episode still crushed all of our emotions. There are many moments to choose from, like Arizona Robbins screaming as her leg is completely destroyed, or Derek having to break his own hand to save himself, but there’s no doubt that the worst moment of the entire episode was watching Lexi Grey slowly die while trapped under the plane. Mark Sloan was there to hold her hand and tell her he loved her, but Lexi should have ended up with Mark, and they should have had cute babies, and she should. not. have. died.
6. Song Beneath The Song
Episode: Season 7, Episode 18
Why we won’t forget it: Judge me all you want, but I loved the musical episode of the show. Yes, i know it was cheesy, but I love musicals and I love Grey’s Anatomy. Not to mention, the episode was extremely emotional.
Callie Torres and Arizona were put through the ringer throughout their relationship, but nothing was more trying than their car accident. Callie, who was pregnant at the time, flew through the windshield and was on death’s door. It wasn’t until her spirit came into her hospital room that Callie finally woke up, and learned that she had a daughter. Watching Sara Ramirez, who plays Callie, sing “The Story” still gives me goosebumps.
7. Going, Going, Gone
Episode: Season 9, Episode 1
Why we won’t forget it: This episode was downright unfair. After the plane crash, we thought Mark was going to be okay…but we were wrong. When Webber explains the “surge” to Mark, where patients who are dying get a last boost of energy before passing away, you knew it wasn’t good.
You could make a solid argument that Mark was the character with the most growth on the series, second maybe to Karev. He went from a womanizing serial bachelor to a man in love and a father. He was just starting a new chapter in his life, and even though Lexi was gone, he still had his daughter Sophia. Sadly, the entire episode was basically a eulogy for McSteamy, and we cried through the entire thing.
8. As We Know It
Episode: Season 2, Episode 17
Why we won’t forget it: “It’s Meredith. The girl with the bomb is Meredith.” This is one of the most iconic lines of the series, and it came towards the end of the second season. Even though we knew Meredith wasn’t going to die (it’s called GREY’S Anatomy, after all) this episode saw our heart rates go through the roof.
The tension the show was able to create in a short amount of time is nothing short of miraculous. Watching the team wheel the hospital bed down the hallway had me on the edge of my seat, especially when they almost hit the stanchion on the floor. Plus, watching the bomb squad guy get blown to bits after you thought everyone would be okay scared the living daylight out of us all.
9. Walk On Water/Drowning On Dry Land
Episode: Season 3, Episode 15 & 16
Why we won’t forget it: I hear a lot of people say that this is when they started watching the show, and to those people I say…what took you so long? The ferry crash episodes were some of the most iconic of the series. Again, you knew Meredith couldn’t die, but the longer she was unconscious, the more you started to wonder…are they actually going to kill her off?
The thing that struck me the most about these episodes were the relationships between all the characters and how much Meredith meant to them. From attendings, to residents, to all the interns, everyone showed genuine concern for her life. Despite the drama and fights that happened between everyone, when one of their own went down they were there to help.
10. Unbreak My Heart
Episode: Season 12, Episode 11
Why we won’t forget it: I am unashamed of my love for “Japril,” which is the couple name of Jackson Avery and April Kepner, of course. Their love story started out as a fun fling, but their feelings for each other grew and grew. Tragedy struck when they lost their first child, Samuel, to a genetic disorder, and they were never the same since then.
This episode showed us the love story of Japril through a series of flashbacks starting at the end and taking us back to the beginning. It let us see where everything went wrong, while also reminding us the love that these two had was absolutely real.
11. Losing My Religion
Episode: Season 2, Episode 27
Why we won’t forget it: Denny Duquette was flawed, yes, but that’s what made him and Izzie Stevens such an intriguing couple. When they first started flirting, I was skeptical, but then things grew into something special and I really was rooting for them.
This episode is the one where Denny died, and we watched Izzie show up to the hospital in her prom dress, only to find out her fiancée had died. Just gut-wrenching. We also had to see Karev pick Izzie up and carry her home, which somehow made things even worse.
12. Deterioration Of The Fight Or Flight Response
Episode: Season 2, Episode 26
Why we won’t forget it: Cutting the LVAD wire was a dumb choice, but in the defense of the interns…they had no idea that Burke was going to be shot in the ambulance bay that night. In theory, though it was insane, their plan made sense. But what you have to remember about Seattle Grace Hospital is that nothing can ever go right.
When Izzie is manually pumping to keep Denny alive, you can feel the fear through the screen. Everyone knows they’ve messed up, everyone knows Denny is dying, and everyone knows nothing will be the same ever again.
13. How To Save A Life
Episode: Season 11, Episode 21
Why we won’t forget it: If you ask me, this is where the show jumped the shark. I know why Derek Shepard had to die, because they didn’t want his and Meredith’s love story to end in divorce, but was this really any better?
We won’t ever forget this episode, because it was a pivotal moment in the series that changed its course forever. However, it was far from perfect. That doesn’t mean we didn’t cry our eyes out, though, when Zola asked Meredith if she was going to be able to fix daddy.
14. Fear (Of The Unknown)
Episode: Season 10, Episode 24
Why we won’t forget it: Cristina Yang was, and remains to this day, one of the best characters to ever appear on Grey’s Anatomy. Even though I hated that she had to leave, I felt like she got to do it on her own terms, and as the best version of herself. Plus, she didn’t leave via a massive tragedy, so let’s call that a win.
Cristina left to better her career, and she made sure to leave Meredith with some of the best advice on the planet. “You are a gifted surgeon with an extraordinary mind. Don’t let what he wants eclipse what you need. He is very dream, but he is not the sun. You are.” Wise, wise words.
15. The Sound Of Silence
Episode: Season 12, Episode 9
Why we won’t forget it: We always knew Meredith and Alex were close, but this was one of the first episodes after Derek’s death that we really witnessed the intense friendship they share. After Meredith is attacked by a patient, Alex is by her side every single step of the way. You can see the fear in his eyes when Meredith is hurt, because you know that they’re not just friends…they’re family.
When Alex brings Meredith’s kids in to see her, he says “you’ve been asking me every day, ‘when can we see Mommy?'” which means he’s been caring for her kids while she’s been in the hospital, or at the very least has been seeing them every day. It shows Alex’s growth, and it shows Meredith’s resilience.
16. Stairway To Heaven
Episode: Season 5, Episode 13
Why we won’t forget it: This episode is the second half of a two-parter, and while most people may not have it on their list, I think it’s a very crucial point in the series. A death row inmate is brought to the hospital, and Meredith is doing her best to find the good in him. Derek doesn’t agree with it, but when Meredith goes to the prison when the patient is killed, Derek is there waiting for her after it happens.
This is also the episode where Izzie finally accepts that there is something wrong with her, and that seeing Denny isn’t just a fun game. Something isn’t right, and she needs to find out what is going on. We all knew from the beginning that it wasn’t going to be good, but watching Izzie finally come to terms with it somehow made it more real.
17. Sanctuary/Death And All His Friends
Episode: Season 6, Episode 23 & 24
Why we won’t forget it: These two episodes are the best in the entire series, and I’ll argue that fact until I’m blue in the face. I could watch them one hundred times and still feel the same tension, despair, and sadness I felt the first time around. I don’t even know where to begin. When you find out there’s a shooter in the hospital, and then see him in the elevator with Cristina, you can’t help but hold your breath.
Then, after Derek gets shot and Cristina is operating on him with Jackson, Meredith telling the gunman to shoot her instead of him is an extremely selfless act of love that we’ll never forget.
But perhaps the most upsetting moment was after Charles Percy got shot, and Miranda Bailey realized all the elevators were on emergency stop and she wasn’t able to get him help. As she sat and cradled Charles in her lap, and he asked if he was dying, the emotion displayed in Bailey’s face was nothing short of heartbreaking.
So there you have it. Our list of the most unforgettable Grey’s Anatomy episodes.